Judith A. Reynolds, 78, of New Castle, passed away peacefully the morning of April 26, 2020 at her residence, surrounded by her family. Born August 20, 1941 in New Castle, she was the daughter of William E. Hiler and Betty (Weatherby) Fry who preceded her in death. She is also preceded by her husbands, Lewis J. Presnar and James L. Reynolds, and former husband George Dudich Sr; two sisters, Helen R. Hiler and Sandra Weatherby Zarilla; and one brother, William Fry. Judith attended New Castle High School and worked as an aide for several families over the years. In her earlier years, she participated in some of her favorite activities such as playing darts and bowling. She also enjoyed hunting, camping, painting ceramics in which she won many awards/ribbons, and motorcycle rides with her husband Jim. She is survived by three daughters, Yvonne "Sissy" (William Jr.) Book, Dianna (David Sr.) Stull, and Cindy Reynolds, all of New Castle; three sons, Lewis J. "Skip" Presnar, George A. (Jane) Dudich Jr. of New Castle, and Daniel E. Dudich of Florida; one sister, Carolyn J. Preisel; two brothers William Hiler and Wallace Hiler all of New Castle; ten grandchildren, Jamie R. Book, Kristilyn M. (Michael) Telesz, William E.J. (Jasmine) Book, David A Stull Jr., Melissa L. (Quincy) Boatner, Shannon L. Dudich, George A. Dudich III, James T. (Kate) Duncan, Nicole Amabile, and Kali N. Dudich; and three great grandchildren. The family would like to thank the amazing caregivers that helped Judith keep her wish of remaining in her home during her brave 3 ½ year battle with cancer. A huge thank you to Dr. Magda, Jenni, and Cheryl of Anova Hospice. Burial will be in Graceland Cemetery. Unfortunately, there will be no visitation or calling hours due to the current circumstances. Arrangements are being handled by the R. Cunningham Funeral Home and Crematory, Inc., where online condolences may be offered at www.cunninghamfh.com